i think that with the CAA forthcoming, a lot may look different in the coming year. perhaps wait a bit and reassess?
we dont exactly have a huge membership here... usually about a dozen online at any given time, and that's really because users stay logged in. i'd say we usually have 10-15 posts per day (most of which are mine!), unless it's a bball/football game, big event, etc.
we have 350 members:
-but only a few dozen regular contributors
-a chunk who joined when we played for example SHSU in the playoffs, the CWS, etc.
-some parents who hang around for 4 years and then generally exit
-over 100 members don't have a single post
-another 100 have under 10 posts.